Review: A Quiet Place

finds John Krasinski’s horror an enjoyable experience, but with wasted potential

Image: Paramount Pictures


Director: John Krasinski

Starring: John Krasinski, Emily Blunt, Millicent Simmonds, Noah Jupe

Length: 1hr 30m

Rating: 15

In A Quiet Place, noise gets you killed. Following in the footsteps of recent high-concept horror films like Dont Breathe and It Follows, John Krasinskis sci-fi horror is set in the near-future where alien creatures have wiped out most of humanity. The creatures, blind but with powerful hearing and both fast and difficult to kill, prey on loud noises and respond to them quickly, making them a deadly opponent for the human race, so reliant as we are on sound for communication. The film focusses on one of the likely few survivors of this apocalypse, a family with a deaf daughter, equipped already with sign language for this now necessarily silent world.

The family, composed of Lee (played by Krasinski), Evelyn (Emily Blunt) and their children Regan (Millicent Simmonds), Marcus (Noah Jupe) and Beau (Cade Woodward), survive on an isolated farm in the huge American countryside, having erred on the side of caution and total precaution. The film is incredibly engaging when highlighting the tiny details that have allowed the family to survive for as long as they have in this hostile environment. Sand has been poured over the

Image: Paramount Pictures

footpaths to muffle footsteps, markings pepper the house floorboards to prevent creaking, and voiced conversation is made only by the louder sound of the nearby rivers rushing water. Lee sends out SOS messages through the radio, and fire-beacons are lit every so often for the few surviving humans to remind each other that, despite their isolation, they are not alone.

The acting reflects this attention to detail, with a wonderful emphasis on body language and facial expressions. All of the performances are great, especially from the child actors, who perfectly convey a sense of fear mixed with childish innocence. In a world where civilisation has been destroyed, angst will still dominate a teenagers mind, especially a deaf girl frustrated by a strained relationship with her father. Regan, played by the herself deaf actress Millicent Simmonds, stands out as a silent but forceful personality, Simmonds conveying her sadness and frustration, but also her bravery and sense of duty all with a deft and natural ability. Noah Jupe, as Marcus, is another stand-out simply for his great expressiveness throughout both the tense quiet moments and later more violent episodes. Heres hoping we see more of these two in the future.

Whereas the premise, details and performances are enjoyable, the horror elements are frustratingly less so. For a film thats supposed to be very quiet, there are a lot of distracting noises. The sound design doesnt have much faith in the smallest of noises building tension, so we are constantly blasted by the loud music every time a noise is made. Its like the film doesnt trust the audience to get that even the slightest of noises is a threat, that there needs to be a scary loud noise to accompany everything to shock us into suspense. This is a film thats perfectly designed for jump-scares, and while theres technically nothing wrong with that, when the jump-scares are non-stop they really start to lose their impact and quickly become obnoxious. If youre able to predict when the scary bitsare going to happen because youre so used to how the jump-scares are being handled, then youre not scared anymore. Some more variety in scares can go a long way in surprising you. Its a shame, because the premise lends itself so well to building up tension and dread anyway. The scariest moment comes when the youngest child, Beau, switches on a little toy shuttle and the noise is heard around the forest. Between the sound being as noisy as it was in this so-far silent world, and the familys horrified expressions responding immediately, its remarkably effective. Its a pity there werent more scenarios developed like this.

Image: Paramount Pictures

The creatures also felt mishandled somewhat. While their design is great, their mystery quickly evaporates the more we see them. As the characters find more ways to outsmart them, you are forced to wonder how these creatures managed to kill off all humanity when they are dealt with by a family on a farm; this becomes an increasingly distracting thought as this is an otherwise slow and quiet film. The sad, moody atmosphere of the films first half also quickly dissipates when we are hit with loud encounter after loud encounter with the creatures, spoiling their mystery as nightmarish entities and robbing the film of its more serious and thoughtful tone. As action its a fun ride, but not really appropriate given the films initial premise.

A Quiet Place is an interesting and enjoyable horror film, but it leaves you with this feeling that there is so much to this idea left untapped and even somewhat wasted. Ironically, the most fun environment to watch it would be in a living room, with friends chatting as you wait for the violent, noisy stuff to happen.

Leave a comment

Please note our disclaimer relating to comments submitted. Please do not post pretending to be another person. Nouse is not responsible for user-submitted content.