Demanding more than just words

HRW urge Miliband to stop deportation to Ethiopia

HRW urge Miliband to stop deportation to Ethiopia

Human Rights Watch UK has today written a letter to David Miliband, the Foreign Secretary, condemning the Memorandum of Understanding signed last year between Britain and Ethiopia.

The letter opens warning that “diplomatic promises are insufficient to prevent torture” before going on to outline the fact that torture is widely used both “in the course of interrogations”, and “as a form of punishment”.

Here is an extract from the latter section:

“Methods of torture include forcing people to strip and subjecting them to repeated and severe kicking and beatings with sticks, electric cables, rifle butts, iron bars, and other instruments, sometimes at gunpoint; tying the individual’s hands and feet and suspending the person upside down and beating them; tying bottles of water to men’s testicles; and forcing detainees to run or crawl barefoot over sharp gravel for several hours at a time. Human Rights Watch has also documented cases of rape of women and girls detained in military barracks in Somali region.

Other patterns of serious violations of international human rights and humanitarian law by Ethiopian military (Ethiopian National Defence Force) and police forces include summary or extrajudicial executions, arbitrary and incommunicado detention, indiscriminate attacks, and rape and sexual violence against civilians. Detainees in police and military custody often lack access to legal counsel, medical care, and family members and are routinely subjected to lengthy pre-charge and pre-trial detention in violation of Ethiopian and international law.”

The letter then makes reference to the role of Ethiopia in the North African Rendition Process, an ongoing barbarity that HRW documented in this 2007 report.

The open letter closes with these words:

“In conclusion, Human Rights Watch is extremely concerned that the UK-Ethiopia MoU will trigger an attempt by the UK to return individuals to a country known to have a serious record of torture and mistreatment of detainees by security forces, in violation of the UK’s legal obligations under UK and international law. We strongly urge you to refrain from implementing the agreement and deporting individuals to Ethiopia, where they will face a serious risk of torture and other abuse.”

They also posted online a report to accompany the letter, which you can read here.

It took the foreign office just under three weeks to respond to my letter regarding Burma. If they have that turnaround time for me, a lowly human rights hack, then they will surely respond quicker to HRW.

We wait and watch with interest…


  1. 18 Sep ’09 at 1:29 am

    Samson Shawel

    God be with HRW.
    I cordially ask Foreign Secretary David Miliband to be care full when implementing the agreement it may expose Ethiopians to be victims of the genocide criminal woyanes. Woyanes may take the agreement for their political interest and members of oppositions may be victimized.

    Woyane or the false Ethiopian government is criminal of genocide like the govenment of Sudan or Bashir. I ask your precious time to read letter of Genocide Watch.

    God be with Ethiopians and UK



    Genocide Watch is the Chair of the International Campaign to End Genocide
    P.O. Box 809, Washington, D.C., USA 20044. Phone: 703-448-0222
    E-mail:[email protected] Website:
    March 23, 2009

    An Open Letter to the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights
    Justice Navanathem Pillay
    Petitions Team
    Office of the United Nations
    High Commissioner for Human Rights
    1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland

    Dear Madame High Commissioner,
    Advocates of justice around the world are thrilled at the strong action the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court has taken in issuing a warrant for the arrest of Omar al-Bashir of the Sudan, resulting in finally holding him accountable for the atrocities being committed in Darfur over the last six years. Under al-Bashir’s leadership, millions of Sudanese from Darfur, as well as from Southern Sudan, have suffered inconceivable harm, injustice and hardship.

    The action that the International Criminal Court has taken in this situation has restored hope to peace and justice loving people, affirming that international human rights law not only exists on paper, but in reality. It also sends an important message to perpetrators throughout the world that impunity for their crimes is not assured forever; which may be a primary reason that one of the first leaders to defend Omar al-Bashir and condemn the warrant was Prime Minister Meles Zenawi of Ethiopia, whose government has also been implicated in a pattern of widespread perpetration of serious human rights atrocities in Ethiopia and in Somalia. He and those within his government may be keenly aware of their own vulnerability to similar actions by the ICC in the future that could upend a deeply entrenched system of government-supported impunity that has protected perpetrators from any accountability.

    I first became knowledgeable regarding the abhorrent human rights situation in Ethiopia when Genocide Watch and Survivors Rights International were called by the head of the Anuak Justice Council, Obang Metho, (now the leader of the newly formed Solidarity Movement for a New Ethiopia) to investigate the brutal massacre of 424 Anuak carried out in Gambella, Ethiopia in December of 2003. The Anuak are a tiny, dark-skinned ethnic group who live in a remote section of southeastern Ethiopia. Ethiopian National Defense Forces (ENDF) and civilian militia groups from another ethnic group utilized a prepared list to target Anuak leaders, many of whom were opposed to the government’s plan to exclude them from any involvement in the drilling for oil on their indigenous land. As militia groups chanted, “Today is the day for killing Anuak,” both the military and militias used machetes, axes and guns to kill the unarmed victims, frequently raping the women while chanting, “Now there will be no more Anuak children.”

    Extra-judicial killings, rape, disappearances, destruction of livelihood and the displacement of thousands of Anuak continued into late 2005 before finally subsiding when the same Ethiopian National Defense Forces were moved to the Ogaden area of southeastern Ethiopia and into Somalia where similar atrocities were and still are being committed. A subsequent investigation of the Anuak massacre by Genocide Watch and Survivors Rights International to determine who was behind the human rights crimes, documented the existence of a plan called “Operation Sunny Mountain,” that could be traced to originating at the highest levels within the central government of Ethiopia.1 1 See: ;
    and updates at ; and .

    Genocide Watch is the Chair of the International Campaign to End Genocide
    P.O. Box 809, Washington, D.C., USA 20044. Phone: 703-448-0222
    E-mail:[email protected] Website:
    As a result of our investigation and based on our experience in international law and genocide, we concluded that the killing of the Anuak in Gambella, Ethiopia, fit the definitions of genocide and crimes against humanity. Human Rights Watch also conducted two investigations of their own and determined that the crimes against the Anuak meet the stringent definition of crimes against humanity. Most of the perpetrators in their report and in ours have never been brought to justice under the Ethiopian justice system due to the failings and corruption of that system. Despite the violation of international law, not only has no one has been held accountable for these crimes which occurred over five years ago, but worse than that, such crimes continue in other places in the country. Only some of these cases have been investigated by respected international human rights organizations, but where they have, findings consistently point to the involvement of the Ethiopian government in the inciting, the empowerment or the perpetration of crimes against humanity, war crimes and even genocide, often justified by them as “counter-insurgency.”

    In light of these facts, I would strongly urge you to initiate an investigation of the situation in Ethiopia based on your proprio motu powers as the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights. We believe that your investigation is justified due to the culture of impunity that exists within Ethiopia. Extensive documentation is available to examine the violations, most of which has been compiled in independent investigative reports completed by international human rights organizations. We also believe that the Ethiopian people have been waiting long enough for genuine justice and relief from the harsh oppression and brutal tactics committed by a government that purports to be a partner in the War on Terror, while terrorizing their own people. Addressing the EPRDF regime, friendly to Omar al-Bashir, may bring greater stability to the entire Horn of Africa. We are willing to provide assistance to you in carrying out this task because we, in Genocide Watch, and other human rights organizations are determined to pursue justice, even long after violations have occurred, as part of our mission. Investigative reports, contacts and other information can be provided should you need them. I thank you for the excellent work you are doing in combating impunity, the enemy of justice. Perpetrators of crimes against humanity must not be allowed to walk free. Genocide Watch will continue to do its part, collaborating with others, in pursuing additional ways to make such crimes carry a heavy penalty. One way is to work with domestic governments to make sure that those Ethiopians who have committed these crimes do not gain access to entry into western countries, something that is now supported through new legislation in many of the western countries. Additionally, in Canada, Europe and in the US, there are now laws giving authority to these governments to prosecute human rights perpetrators found within their new countries of residence should admissible evidence be found to charge them. The western countries should no longer act as a haven for such criminals.

    Thank you for your consideration of this request for the initiation of an investigation of genocide, crimes
    against humanity and war crimes in Ethiopia. We look forward to hearing from you.

    Sincerely yours,
    Dr. Gregory Stanton,
    President of Genocide Watch

    Obama scolded Ethiopia’s dictator Meles Zenawi
    April 3rd, 2009 | Categories: Ethiopia | 19 Comments
    U.S. President Barack Obama scolded Ethiopia’s dictator Meles Zenawi during a brief one-to-one encounter at he G20 meeting in London on April 2. Obama reportedly told Meles that the human rights condition in Ethiopia as deplorable and unacceptable.
    Following a meeting with Obama, Meles Zenawi, who was invited to represent New Partnership for African Development (NEPAD) at the G20 meeting, abruptly canceled a press conference he was about to give.
    “His people gave no reasons for this. But insiders in the press center said Zenawi was worried about the kind of questions that were going to be put to him concerning human rights violations within Ethiopia and his dealing with his opponents and Ethiopia’s neighbors,” Henry Gombya of BSN reported. “The African continent really wasn’t heard; South African President Motlanthe said he didn’t speak for the continent and Meles Zenawi cowered in the shadows,” Gombya

    Reply Report

  2. I am bekele i come from ethiopian . i live now uk.I live in uk near 7 years. i am falie asuylem sekeer.homeoffice said to me go to ethiopia. and abuse .

    Reply Report

Leave a comment

Please note our disclaimer relating to comments submitted. Please do not post pretending to be another person. Nouse is not responsible for user-submitted content.