The limits of hope: an ode to Barack Obama

Obama came on a promise of hope and prosperity. After eight years of Presidency, where did it all go wrong?

Image: Glyn Lowe

I really do want to look back upon Barack Obama’s presidency in a fond light. He came promising hope, iconised in artist Shepard Fairey’s stencil portrait poster. He was the light after eight years of darkness. He was the first non-white President, and represented a wave of change for the better. So long to the days of Wall Street recklessness, hello to regulation.

And yet, I do feel like I’m looking back on Obama through rose-tinted glasses. Hope is important – the Star Wars saga has spent eight films drilling that concept into the zeitgeist – but after election and the assumption of public office, hope for change is, frankly, not good enough. For all of Obama’s greatest achievements, and please, don’t think that I do not recognise and welcome the progress he has made, there have been a calamitous number of failures.

Then again, he has had tremendous obstacles and forces fighting against him. He was elected at the height of the global financial crisis and helped to rescue the US economy. Republicans held majorities in both houses for most of his Presidency and blocked him at every turn on many of his initiatives. And while the Democrats did have a majority when he first took office, the argument that he had to spend that time fixing the flailing economy before he could move on to other policy areas is one I understand.

I remember watching an episode of Panorama in early 2012 (at the tender age of 13, when politics was still largely something I had no clue about) that looked at “Poor America”, and how Obama’s 2008 election vision for the United States was dead. From what I can recall – and bear in mind that this was five years ago – all of the interviewees agreed on one matter: that their President had failed them. In siding with the banks, and leaving the system largely unchanged from the one of reckless capitalism that lead to the financial crisis, Obama arguably alienated the poor, the C2DE, the “forgotten America”, whatever you want to dub them. In many ways, no wonder they voted Trump, even if he is inevitably going to shaft them even more.

A recent article in the Washington Times declared foreign policy to be the Obama administration’s biggest failure; Moscow is on the rise, relations with western Europe have been “called into question”; relations with Israel and Saudi Arabia are less than great. Even for those in the camp that agree with Obama and Secretary Kerry’s last minute intervention in the recent Israel-Palestine land building conflict can argue that after years of vetoing UN resolutions that it comes as too little, too late.

Obama is better that the alternatives; those who immediately preceded and will follow him and those he ran against. But simply being better than the alternative does not make one intrinsically good. Guantanamo is still open, the social gap has widened, deportations are at a high. The victory for equal marriage came from the Supreme Court and not the executive, Obamacare is already being dismantled, Obama’s victories on climate change through executive orders will surely be reversed.

To return to Star Wars, in Rogue One protagonist Jyn Erso proclaims that “rebellions are built on hope”’. Yet Obama discovered that once the rebellion is over, hope is simply not enough. He may have been the best of statesmen, who aimed to rise above party politics, and has remained untarnished by scandal unlike many of his predecessors, but although this is still an ode to Obama, it’s an ode to the Obama that could have been: not the one he actually was.

One comment

  1. Obama might not have been as bad as Nixon/Kissinger, but his Presidency is certainly worse than suggested here. The phrase ‘untarnished by scandal’ has been frequently repeated across the web, and is particularly inane. Obamacare is a bureaucratic nightmare for countless reasons, and the IRS was used to target conservatives to push the ACA through. That’s scandal one. The NSA scandal saw millions of civilian emails and phone calls collected in violation of fourth amendment rights. He also stacked his administration with lobbyists and the NLRB with unionists (the latter without Congressional approval), while giving tax dollars to ‘green energy’ companies whose shareholders had made substantial donations to his campaign. Beyond that you’ve got the ATF scandal, which saw untraceable guns walked across the Arizona-Mexico border, and the mess that was Benghazi. All this is not to mention the ridiculous arms initiatives in the Middle East, the ludicrous bailing out of General Motors, the failed attempt to fix the banks via the Dodd-Frank reforms, and the deterioration of race-relations. The genius of Obama was his expansion of the administration to such an extent as to maintain his plausible deniability when things went wrong.

    I also have an issue with the suggestion that Moscow being on the rise is categorically disastrous. The relentless haranguing of Russia twenty-five years after the Cold War is boring, and I hope that the Trump administration will, if nothing else, foster better relations with Russia.

    Reply Report

Leave a comment

Please note our disclaimer relating to comments submitted. Please do not post pretending to be another person. Nouse is not responsible for user-submitted content.