A High Society

Chris Tyler, Chairman of British Mensa, talks to about intellectual elitism, the limits of the IQ test and why we shouldn’t call people carrots

Photo credit: Chris Tyler

Photo credit: Chris Tyler

The Chairman of British Mensa, Chris Tyler, does not in any way come across as elitist, pretentious or, surprisingly, excessively intellectual. This is just as well because, with membership steadily decreasing, Mensa is trying to detach itself from these types of stereotypical perception.

“It is a problem; I think people might be reluctant to join because they’re worried that they would be seen with all the negative associations that come with it,” explains Chris. “Maybe if we had a positive image and people actually celebrated intelligence”.

According to him, this is related to more than the single organisation. “People seem quite happy to knock people for achievement”. It seems instead to be more of a cultural issue. “It’s something that’s perhaps unique to Britain, or certainly Britain and one or two other countries”.

“In America, Mensa’s seen as very much aspirational. In Britain we don’t like to boast that we’re clever and the popular image in the press is to put intelligent people down as eggheads or boffins. Probably ten years ago, Mensa actually had quite a bad image; there was negative publicity in the press”.

Mensa is a society for those with a high IQ. It derives from the word “table” in Latin, the idea being that, as is the legend of the Round Table, all are equal in the organisation. Founded in Britain in 1946 by Roland Berrill and Dr Lance Ware, it has approximately 22,000 members in Britain and over 100,000 globally. Only the top 2% of the population with the highest IQ scores are eligible to join. This may seem like a tiny fragment of society at first glance, however this allows approximately one in every fifty to join: “If you consider that 2% of the population are eligible to join, you’re probably talking about something in the region of 1.2 million people”.

More than anything, the organisation is a social group; a place for people of high intelligence to meet. There are local and national events, sometimes meetings with a special focus on a particular subject, forums exclusively for members and there is a monthly magazine. The society also plays a role in research into intelligence.

Photo credit: phonono

Photo credit: phonono

Chris himself first joined Mensa simply out of natural curiosity. “Really it was to find out what my IQ was”. After doing a short test which he found in a newspaper, he ordered a home test from Mensa which indicated that he may be eligible to join. He then took a supervised test to get an official IQ score and subsequently joined up.

However for 15 to 20 years he did not get involved; he was a member but he did not take part in anything organised by Mensa. He believes that to be fairly common amongst members. “They pay their subscription and they don’t take a lot out in way of servicing their membership … Perhaps if they took action and got involved, they might get more enjoyment from it. Sometimes that takes a trigger, for them to become active”, he suggests. “You know, maybe splitting up with a partner, or moving out of an area, and looking for a new social group”.

By and large, it is the social aspect of Mensa that Chris revels in. “Perhaps one of the bigger meetings, or possibly a smaller meeting, where lots of members get together and we just have a chat; not the popular misconception of discussing astrophysics or popular science. It tends to be exactly the same conversations that work colleagues, schoolmates, friends will get together and discuss. The difference is that they tend to cover a far wider range of topics”.

This popular misconception of Mensa members as ostentatious intellects, arguing about theoretical physics appears to be the primary concern of the Society. The latest publicity that Mensa received has not been good. During a recent interview for BBC Breakfast, a spokesman for the organisation deemed people with IQs of around 60 to be nothing but “carrots”. Although this was not a critical news story, it is a major problem for an organisation which is trying to turn its back on the snobbish reputation it has acquired.

This hostile atmosphere means that many members are likely to hide their intelligence, or at least not boast about it. Apparently one particular issue that has been greatly discussed on forums is whether to mention a high IQ on a CV, and how doing so would affect employment prospects. Some members worry that employers would be concerned about employing people who were cleverer than themselves, or that bosses would feel threatened by them. However, as Chris points out, we must remember that IQ is only a genetic attribute. It is not an automatic ticket to success and will not be helpful unless you put in the hard work.

It is easy to see how a high IQ could lead to bullying, especially when it comes to highly intelligent children. Chris believes that these problems are something for schools to deal with effectively and should be part of tackling bullying as a whole; not an issue which Mensa should tackle. “You know, in school, as a general rule, schoolchildren don’t like people who don’t fit the norm… it’s a risk but then that’s down to the schools to manage that risk”.

Mensa does, meanwhile, appear keen to support intelligent children, with its “Gifted and Talented Support Programme”, which offers advice and support to parents and teachers of gifted or talented children. Intelligent children are invited to join Mensa and are catered for. According to its website, one of the founding principles of the organisation is “to identify and foster human intelligence”, and Chris whole-heartedly agrees with this. “It’s absolutely vital to get the best out of people with high intelligence”.

But is IQ even a decent measure of intelligence? If it only demonstrates genetic qualities, how can we overlook other factors such as determination and hard work, as reputable? Perhaps unsurprisingly, the answer I get is in favour of the tests. After all, the whole idea of Mensa would contain a major flaw without an accurate way to measure intelligence. “IQ is really measuring your ability to think, it’s measuring your ability to solve problems, measuring your ability to understand, to investigate… However, IQ doesn’t give us the full picture of a person’s mental ability”.

Photo credit: thorr_matt83

Photo credit: thorr_matt83

Chris compares IQ to sporting prowess in order to come up with an analogy. “[IQ] is a very good measure, but really having that ability doesn’t mean you’re going to put it into practise, in the same way that there are perhaps people who have the physical capabilities of being faster than Usain Bolt but aren’t prepared to put the hours of training in to realise that potential”.

So, bearing in mind that membership is declining, is a society for highly intelligent people necessary today? “I do believe that Mensa does offer something that perhaps might not be available”, says Chris. “There are also a lot of people who potentially struggle with high intelligence; again it sort of offers them a forum, a network of people to communicate with. But the reality is, like any social organisation, no, we’re not needed, but I do think we fulfil our niche”.

For an organisation that is bound closely to its social group, it must be disappointing to see that group shrinking. As well as that lack of positive publicity which has been problematic for Mensa for many years, Chris offers a couple of other explanations. “The economic climate is probably a factor, with people deciding that they can no longer afford to pay membership. Another factor is the rise of social media, as electronic social media is becoming more and more common, perhaps some people have less need for a sort of social port or social organisation, or of the opportunity to meet with people”.

It is not, however, the case that they will accept this decline. Mensa is now moving towards taking full advantage of social media. “We’ve got our own Facebook page, plus some of the local groups have set up their own. We’ve got a LinkedIn group, which is restricted to members only, and that’s grown quite substantially in size… We see members coming along to those who we’ve not seen at other events, so it might be that they don’t attend events but, in setting up a LinkedIn group, they’re happy to go there and talk to members”.

It seems that Chris wants to be as open as possible about Mensa in order to dispel the perceptions which surround it. He encourages anyone with misconceptions of its members to come to a meeting. “I’ve had many, many late nights sat in a bar having great discussions about the most mundane of subjects. Anyone sat in there would not in any way think that we were a pretentious group”. Mensa appears to be very aware that in order to remain the significant society it strives to be, it must find a way to adapt, alongside battling against those who perceive it to be an elitist institution.

One comment

  1. Anyone who feels compelled to join Mensa clearly has some deep-rooted issues. Mitchell says it best: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPMKqyaXtHI

    Reply Report

Leave a comment

Please note our disclaimer relating to comments submitted. Please do not post pretending to be another person. Nouse is not responsible for user-submitted content.