<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><!-- generator="wordpress/2.2.1" -->
<rss version="2.0" 
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/">
<channel>
	<title>Comments on: US nuclear deal with India angers Iran</title>
	<link>http://www.nouse.co.uk/2006/03/14/us-nuclear-deal-with-india-angers-iran/</link>
	<description>Award-winning University of York Student Newspaper</description>
	<pubDate>Thu, 21 Aug 2008 04:01:47 +0000</pubDate>
	<generator>http://wordpress.org/?v=2.2.1</generator>

	<item>
		<title>By: K. Deshmukh</title>
		<link>http://www.nouse.co.uk/2006/03/14/us-nuclear-deal-with-india-angers-iran/#comment-14721</link>
		<author>K. Deshmukh</author>
		<pubDate>Sat, 19 Aug 2006 08:29:31 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid>http://www.nouse.co.uk/2006/03/14/us-nuclear-deal-with-india-angers-iran/#comment-14721</guid>
		<description>As India and the US have now reached agreement on the historic nuclear deal, there has been a huge public debate on it. At the moment, Indian opponents are reacting very strongly. They think the agreement will constrain India’s future nuclear development and national freedom &#38; dignity have been sold out. 

But personally I welcome this Indo-US nuclear deal. Because this deal will help India to reap a lot of economic benefits. Through the deal, the US, strategically, accepts India’s nuclear prowess, thus strengthening India’s geopolitical position. Not only this, the deal is also bound to boost India’s chances to make it to the United Nations Security Council. 

India is the largest democracy in the world that requires capital to build its infrastructure and manufacturing base and also nuclear energy for its development. With assistance of US and Europe, India can attain 8 per cent economic growth over the next decade.

According to the Planning Commission, India needs to increase its power supply five to seven times to sustain a steady growth of eight per cent per annum till 2031. It is reasonably unlikely that the options available will see India through. The nuclear deal that will help India import Uranium ore and civilian nuclear technology from the developed countries, including the US, can just solve the puzzle of "How to meet India’s growing power needs?” 
 
So, I think India will get triangular benefits by this deal i.e. Economical, Political, Military 

I would like to suggest a nuclear deal related article here &#62;&#62; http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=123348&#38;catID=2&#38;category=Nation&#38;rtFlg=rtFlg</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As India and the US have now reached agreement on the historic nuclear deal, there has been a huge public debate on it. At the moment, Indian opponents are reacting very strongly. They think the agreement will constrain India’s future nuclear development and national freedom &amp; dignity have been sold out. </p>
<p>But personally I welcome this Indo-US nuclear deal. Because this deal will help India to reap a lot of economic benefits. Through the deal, the US, strategically, accepts India’s nuclear prowess, thus strengthening India’s geopolitical position. Not only this, the deal is also bound to boost India’s chances to make it to the United Nations Security Council. </p>
<p>India is the largest democracy in the world that requires capital to build its infrastructure and manufacturing base and also nuclear energy for its development. With assistance of US and Europe, India can attain 8 per cent economic growth over the next decade.</p>
<p>According to the Planning Commission, India needs to increase its power supply five to seven times to sustain a steady growth of eight per cent per annum till 2031. It is reasonably unlikely that the options available will see India through. The nuclear deal that will help India import Uranium ore and civilian nuclear technology from the developed countries, including the US, can just solve the puzzle of &#8220;How to meet India’s growing power needs?” </p>
<p>So, I think India will get triangular benefits by this deal i.e. Economical, Political, Military </p>
<p>I would like to suggest a nuclear deal related article here &gt;&gt; <a href="http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=123348&amp;catID=2&amp;category=Nation&amp;rtFlg=rtFlg" rel="nofollow">http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=123348&amp;catID=2&amp;category=Nation&amp;rtFlg=rtFlg</a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Dhanoop Jose</title>
		<link>http://www.nouse.co.uk/2006/03/14/us-nuclear-deal-with-india-angers-iran/#comment-11505</link>
		<author>Dhanoop Jose</author>
		<pubDate>Sun, 30 Jul 2006 17:35:13 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid>http://www.nouse.co.uk/2006/03/14/us-nuclear-deal-with-india-angers-iran/#comment-11505</guid>
		<description>NEED FOR NUCLEAR POWER
If a third world war occurs it will not be  fought for land,money,supremacy..etc . it will be fought for energy and water.As we all know ,we are now passing  through the most rapid phase of industrialization,so our need for energy will never end.Many developing countries like India,Brazil,South africa,China(sorry,i still don't consider china as a developed country). are  at  top gear on their  path to push themself on to the front row of the world.For the last two decades the energy need is almost doubled.
                                     
So can we say everything is going smoothly?....No we can't, the problem that arises is  how the energy requirements of these gaints and growing gaints can be fulfilled?.There is one and only one answer for that is "NUCLEAR POWER".We can't rely on the petroleum power anymore because it will extinct within next 100 years if our fuel requirements are going on this rate.So nuclear power is the one and only final answer to us.

NUCLEAR POWER UTILIZATION:
 We can compare the nuclear power to a coin, then construction and destruction are it's two sides .That is we can utilize nuclear power for constructive and destructive purposes
 a) Destructive application:As the term "destructive means" it can cause the total destruction of earth.Now a day nuclear weapon technology is highly developed it's effects will thousands of times more than the bomb's that hit's  Hiroshima and Nagasaki, that means complete destruction.Today there are 7 countries who posses nuclear power and many countries possessing nuclear technology.If these technology goes into hands of anti-social elements it will the end of everything.
 b) Costructive application:We can say that nuclear power is our future fuel since we don't have anyother options.So to satisfy the energy requirements of these billions of people in the world, the reasearch and development in the nuclear field is a must.The main advantage of nuclear power is that we can deliver the energy at low cost compared to the other perishable sources of power.

MANAGEMENT OF NUCLEAR POWER:
     We have right to live,right to breath,right to freedom , so as the  time demands every countries must have right to posses nuclear power.The nuclear right must be possessed only in such a way that it should be only utilized for developmental activities.How can we achieve a balance in distribution of these division of nuclear power.

CURRENTS TREATIES:
   The Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) is a treaty which is signed for restricting the possession of nuclear weapons.This treaty was first proposed by irland.This treaty is effective in controlling the nuclear race .Then what is the problem?.why can't we say that this thistreaty is not a full succsess?.Five states are permitted by the NPT to own nuclear weapons they are United States,China,Russia,England and France.They are playing a two sided game by developing and making weapons themself and not allowing others to make it.
If these so-called gaints are really aiming for the security of the world they must first stop themselves from making these weapons.So i think this NPT treaty will only help to create sense superiority or inferiority complex between these countries.So new treaty is needed where all countries are treated as equals.India had tested nuclear weapon can we consider as culprit?.No we can't ,because the situation demands them  to make nuclear weapon since their neighbors china posses the nuclear weapons.So if we need a nuclear weapon free world we need a "NEW TREATY" in which every countries are treated equally.

SOLUTION:We can build large nuclear power plants under the fully control of United Nations and andcan suppley the energy to different countries.This will helps to make the nuclear treaty more worthfull.So that no country have carry out nuclear development for power requirements.This also allow us  to figure the countries who carrying out nuclear test for destructive purpose

CONCLUSION(MY VIEWS): Why this developed countries who already posses nuclear power trying stop other developing countires from developing nuclear technology?.Is it only because of their fear of nuclear weapons?.I think these developed countries don't like other developing countries attaining self dependency in power requirements.They always want to remain as  the rulers of the world.So the big question arise is that "DEVELOPED COUNTRIES FEAR WEAPONS OR OTHER COUNTRIES ATTAINING SELF DEPENDENCY IN NUCLEAR ENERGY MOST?........who knows????

(I am Dhanoop jose from India doing final engineering in computer science.Please give feed about my view.my mail id is dhanoopjose@yahoo.com)</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>NEED FOR NUCLEAR POWER<br />
If a third world war occurs it will not be  fought for land,money,supremacy..etc . it will be fought for energy and water.As we all know ,we are now passing  through the most rapid phase of industrialization,so our need for energy will never end.Many developing countries like India,Brazil,South africa,China(sorry,i still don&#8217;t consider china as a developed country). are  at  top gear on their  path to push themself on to the front row of the world.For the last two decades the energy need is almost doubled.</p>
<p>So can we say everything is going smoothly?&#8230;.No we can&#8217;t, the problem that arises is  how the energy requirements of these gaints and growing gaints can be fulfilled?.There is one and only one answer for that is &#8220;NUCLEAR POWER&#8221;.We can&#8217;t rely on the petroleum power anymore because it will extinct within next 100 years if our fuel requirements are going on this rate.So nuclear power is the one and only final answer to us.</p>
<p>NUCLEAR POWER UTILIZATION:<br />
 We can compare the nuclear power to a coin, then construction and destruction are it&#8217;s two sides .That is we can utilize nuclear power for constructive and destructive purposes<br />
 a) Destructive application:As the term &#8220;destructive means&#8221; it can cause the total destruction of earth.Now a day nuclear weapon technology is highly developed it&#8217;s effects will thousands of times more than the bomb&#8217;s that hit&#8217;s  Hiroshima and Nagasaki, that means complete destruction.Today there are 7 countries who posses nuclear power and many countries possessing nuclear technology.If these technology goes into hands of anti-social elements it will the end of everything.<br />
 b) Costructive application:We can say that nuclear power is our future fuel since we don&#8217;t have anyother options.So to satisfy the energy requirements of these billions of people in the world, the reasearch and development in the nuclear field is a must.The main advantage of nuclear power is that we can deliver the energy at low cost compared to the other perishable sources of power.</p>
<p>MANAGEMENT OF NUCLEAR POWER:<br />
     We have right to live,right to breath,right to freedom , so as the  time demands every countries must have right to posses nuclear power.The nuclear right must be possessed only in such a way that it should be only utilized for developmental activities.How can we achieve a balance in distribution of these division of nuclear power.</p>
<p>CURRENTS TREATIES:<br />
   The Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) is a treaty which is signed for restricting the possession of nuclear weapons.This treaty was first proposed by irland.This treaty is effective in controlling the nuclear race .Then what is the problem?.why can&#8217;t we say that this thistreaty is not a full succsess?.Five states are permitted by the NPT to own nuclear weapons they are United States,China,Russia,England and France.They are playing a two sided game by developing and making weapons themself and not allowing others to make it.<br />
If these so-called gaints are really aiming for the security of the world they must first stop themselves from making these weapons.So i think this NPT treaty will only help to create sense superiority or inferiority complex between these countries.So new treaty is needed where all countries are treated as equals.India had tested nuclear weapon can we consider as culprit?.No we can&#8217;t ,because the situation demands them  to make nuclear weapon since their neighbors china posses the nuclear weapons.So if we need a nuclear weapon free world we need a &#8220;NEW TREATY&#8221; in which every countries are treated equally.</p>
<p>SOLUTION:We can build large nuclear power plants under the fully control of United Nations and andcan suppley the energy to different countries.This will helps to make the nuclear treaty more worthfull.So that no country have carry out nuclear development for power requirements.This also allow us  to figure the countries who carrying out nuclear test for destructive purpose</p>
<p>CONCLUSION(MY VIEWS): Why this developed countries who already posses nuclear power trying stop other developing countires from developing nuclear technology?.Is it only because of their fear of nuclear weapons?.I think these developed countries don&#8217;t like other developing countries attaining self dependency in power requirements.They always want to remain as  the rulers of the world.So the big question arise is that &#8220;DEVELOPED COUNTRIES FEAR WEAPONS OR OTHER COUNTRIES ATTAINING SELF DEPENDENCY IN NUCLEAR ENERGY MOST?&#8230;&#8230;..who knows????</p>
<p>(I am Dhanoop jose from India doing final engineering in computer science.Please give feed about my view.my mail id is <a href="mailto:dhanoopjose@yahoo.com)">dhanoopjose@yahoo.com)</a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
</channel>
</rss>
